What'd y'all think of this year's top ten idols?

1. Ramiele: A consistent underperformer at this point. Its especially frustrating because it really seems like she could do better - but doesnt, so I think shes likely going home.

2. Jason Castro: He ditched the Mr. Rogers sweater & went back to what works for him: the stool, the bare feet, & the guitar. His fans will love the Spanish lyrics he threw in. Im a fan too, just not like these screaming preteen girls. He does seem too relaxed when he plays, but I guess thats better than trying to sing with a stick shoved up your ass. During the talk with Ryan afterward, it was like a little light went on, his expression became temporarily alert & he remembered to pander to his niche by busting out the peace sign.

3. Syesha Mercado: We knew she could sing like this already but it was still a nice surprise to see her knock it out the park. If she can manage to do this every time she will be a force to be reckoned with.

4. Chikezie: A very dull off night. Hes sang Luther a while back I think & sounded good, but this time it was just bland. It just might be bland enough to get him sweating next to Ramiele tonight.

5. Brooke White: I didnt like the mix, & the performance lacked a certain spark. A case of right track but wrong train. She might hit the bottom three but shes not going anywhere still.

6. Michael Johns: Another Queen song for him, but this time it was the right mix. His brightest moment by far, as his star seems to be on the slow but steady rise. He seems to be improving as the show progresses.

7. Carly Smithson: I suppose it was inevitable that she sing this song. It was either this or Paradise By the Dashboard Light. More of that 'theatrical drama rock' I mentioned before. She's still solid, but I think her luster is wearing off the fans.

8. David Archuleta: I did not like the song. He only did a decent job with the vocal, but it was sooooo Disney. He should have been surrounded by muppets & care bears for better effect.

9. Kristy Lee Cook: I just spotted her image in the dictionary next to the word 'pander'. I gotta give it to her, it was one of the most cunning song choices Ive ever seen on the show. Plus she actually did a good job of it. She knew she was on borrowed time. Now, if you dont vote for her, youre a terrorist. Brilliant!

10. David Cook: he really seems to know how to work this competition better than just about any other contestant to hit that stage. He sang Chris Cornell singing Michael Jackson, but I suspect that Cook's version will instantly eclipse Cornell's to the point where most folks will accept it as Cook's mix. At this rate he'll be going platinum before the competition ends!